Michael Stevenson: Not as they seem
Youssef Nabil creates situations that linger between night and day; liminal moments, between our worldly realities and
deep, carefree sleep, where the concerns of time are absent and dreams serene. Our minds wander, desires are alerted;
the pictures bring back memories of lovers undisturbed, sleeping late. Who is this boy? A burly, hairy leg, the muscular
bicep, his sensuous lips, his dark brows and pronounced eyelashes, the curve of his arse, the unshaven face, the large
forearm, the soft nipple, the dark pubic hair; lust stirs. Let’s lie beside him, in his arms, him in our arms, asleep, away
from reality and responsibility, entranced in an embrace.
Then we remember we are viewers and this is a photograph. We are transgressing, voyeurs intruding on an intimate,
sacred space reserved for sleep and tender love.
The boys continue to sleep. Eyes closed, they lie on their sides, vulnerable, often naked, entwined with sheets and on
rose-patterned cloths, unaware of us. But they are aware. The scenes are carefully composed; the boys are complicit
in these intimate encounters. Nabil leaves us uncertain of fact and fiction, evoking situations on the edge of our
awareness, between self-conscious and subconscious, between him and his friends. Scenes are played out on beds,
places of rest and of dreams, in shadow and soft light, away from the sun and the scrutiny of the world. In these
pictures, silence resonates, emotions are subdued. Still, we find ourselves wondering if these situations involve love or
lust, affection or passion. And even as we acknowledge these uncertainties, we set out on our own journey trying to
understand the conflicting emotions stirred by the ambiguities Nabil has initiated.
Between the odalisques Nabil intersperses portraits of himself. He positions himself as both viewer and subject, as he
lies in bed smoking next to a doll, or naked beside a fire, or on a beach, head down with a distant moon in a dark sky.
At the end of the sequence, he turns away on a beach in Rio at sunset, and, finally, looks down into the sea on the
shores of Havana in daylight. Again this unsettles the viewer’s mind and eye – when is this an image of Nabil, when
is it of others? This counterpoint also makes us wonder about the relationships between photographs and between the
boys and Nabil – are they friends, lovers, or simply models in dreamy tableaux?
In other respects, too, these seemingly innocent scenarios are not as they seem. We notice Arabic text on a book on a
bedside table, an Egyptian carpet, a shisha, the Middle Eastern thaubs the boys wear, their dark features, their names
– Mohamed, Amir, Yassin, Ahmed, Rashid – and the titles, such as Not afraid to love and What have we done wrong.
Slowly, we realise that these scenes of intimacy are transgressive in the milieu of Arabic culture. Such tenderness can only manifest itself secretly in the privacy of a bedroom; it cannot have a life outdoors for all to see and share. It belongs
to a twilight zone and must remain hidden there.
Nabil’s imagery subtly shifts the way we see the realms of sleep and of intimacy, particularly between men. Such
imagery is rarely acknowledged in Western art practice; the line drawings of David Hockney or the photographs of
Wolfgang Tillmans come to mind. In the history of art, the male nude is rarely portrayed quietly on its own terms. It
has had a life as motif in mythology or religious imagery and on the edge of pornography. By contrast, Nabil’s nudes
are considered and conscious, and they alter our perception of a space and a realm where we spend the greater part of
our lives, yet generally ignore once we wake.
Through hand-colouring and tinting his silver gelatin prints, Nabil also discreetly disrupts our notion of the medium.
His process recalls the acts of both painting and photography, and in terms of photography these are, and are not,
colour photographs. Nabil’s colouring alludes perhaps to an imagined era when life was less rushed and love innocent;
to his hometown Cairo, in the cosmopolitan war and pre-revolutionary years, photographed so evocatively by the
Armenian-Egyptian Van Leo who conveyed the fantasies and flamboyance of Egyptian and expatriate society and
movie stars. The tones are nostalgic, evoking moments of longing, distant in time and place. Yet, on looking closely,
it is apparent that these boys are of our time. We realise, once again, that these scenes are not as they seem. As this
realisation dawns, we return to the present, set aside our fantasies, our sadness, and continue with our lives, albeit
reluctantly, in daylight.
Michael Stevenson
Cape Town, May 2007